In Cumming This Fall, Builders Are Setting the Price Resale Homes Have to Beat
On October 1, 2026, Freddie Mac put the national average 30-year fixed mortgage rate at 7.28%. Two days later, Toll Brothers at The Crossing at Coal Mountain in Cumming was advertising 5.25%, or 5.51% APR, on a 30-year fixed loan for select homes. It was also offering up to $40,000 in limited-time incentives on select home sites. A seller three miles away with a five-year-old house can't match that rate unless they pay for it. In Forsyth County this fall, a resale home is being compared with that kind of offer before it's compared with the house next door.
So the comps a buyer looks at in Cumming today are only part of the picture. The real benchmark is what a builder is offering on a similar new home, measured in monthly payment, and that number is lower than most resale list prices suggest.
These offers were live on builder sites at the start of October. All of them are time-limited and apply only to select or eligible homes.
| Community | Builder | What's on the table |
|---|---|---|
| The Crossing at Coal Mountain | Toll Brothers | Up to $40,000 in incentives on select home sites; 5.25% 30-year fixed, 5.51% APR, on select homes during an Oct. 3 through Oct. 18 event |
| Haven Collection townhomes at The Crossing | Toll Brothers | Included appliances, up to $10,000 toward closing costs with Toll Brothers Mortgage Company, same 5.25% rate offer |
| Atlanta-area quick move-in homes | Taylor Morrison | 5.49% fixed, 5.60% APR, on contracts written 10/1/26 through 10/31/26, plus up to $6,000 from the seller; requires the affiliated lender and a seller-selected closing agent |
| Haven Abbey | D.R. Horton | 4110 Haven Way, 5 bedrooms, 3,773 sq. ft., listed at $669,976, down from $719,976 |
| Stratford Hills | Taylor Morrison | Kenwood at 8935 Avonbrook Close at $669,990, down from $758,490; Kirkwood at 8845 Chesford Grove at $584,990, down from $635,180 |
One detail matters at Stratford Hills. Taylor Morrison markets the community under Cumming, but the Kirkwood home carries a Ball Ground 30107 address. Before using it as a comparison for a Forsyth County resale home, confirm which county it sits in.
The table shows builders using two tools at once. One is a lower list price. The other is cheaper money. A resale seller usually reaches for the first one. Builders' affiliated lenders make the second one easy for them to offer.
The rate gap is easy to read past, so here is a simple illustration. It covers principal and interest only and leaves out taxes, insurance, HOA dues and any lender's actual terms.
That last number explains this fall's market. A buyer comparing a resale home with a Coal Mountain new build may see a list price gap of $30,000 or $40,000. The payment gap can be much bigger. The $50,000 cut at 4110 Haven Way and the $88,500 cut on the Kenwood plan at Stratford Hills are real reductions. Even so, both are smaller than the price cut it would take to match a two-point rate difference at today's average rate.
Not every buyer will qualify for a builder's rate, and these offers come with conditions such as an affiliated lender, a select home site or a contract deadline. Your loan officer can confirm the numbers for your situation. The point of the illustration is to show where the competitive pressure comes from.
Georgia MLS county data shows the effect. In September 2026, 176 single-family homes sold in Forsyth County, at an average price of $680,661. In September 2025, 213 homes sold, at an average of $720,510. That's roughly 17% fewer sales and an average sale price about 5.5% lower in one year.
Meanwhile, the county has 1,093 active single-family listings, with an average asking price of $820,708. That's about $140,000 above the average price of homes that actually closed in September. Some of that gap comes from which homes are on the market, since larger and newer homes pull the average up. Still, it shows what's piling up. The homes that are selling are priced well below the ones still waiting.
Divide active listings by September's sales and you get a rough figure of about six months' worth of homes on the market at the current pace. That's our own estimate from Georgia MLS figures. It compares a live listing count with one month of closings and isn't a published months-of-supply number. For comparison, the same calculation for Cherokee County, Forsyth's western neighbor, comes to just under five months. Cherokee's average sale price was also nearly flat year over year, $569,701 in September 2025 versus $570,218 in September 2026. Forsyth's softening is specific to Forsyth.
The FMLS-compiled 400 North Board of REALTORS® brief for August 2026 points the same way. Forsyth County sales declined year over year and month over month, the median sale price held relatively steady at $619,000, and active listings were up 9.9% year over year. Read together, the two sources fit a simple pattern. Inventory is growing, sales are slowing, and the homes that do close are going for less than the asking prices on the market.
All of these figures are county-wide. The Georgia MLS numbers are averages, not medians, and Forsyth County includes more than the city of Cumming. Still, Cumming makes up a large share of the county's housing, and the builder offers above are on Cumming-branded communities.
Builder pressure won't let up once October's promotions end. Forsyth County News reported on October 2, 2026, that construction is underway on Cloverhill, a new Toll Brothers community of 315 townhomes and houses near Cumming City Center. The paper photographed site work between Vision Drive and Canton Road on September 29. The full story gives the scale.
That's close to the city center, not out on the county's edge. Elsewhere in Cumming, Pulte's Oakwood community lists homes from $577,990 with six quick move-in homes available. D.R. Horton's Thalley Creek Estates shows eight homes for sale, starting at $609,990. Quick move-in homes matter most here because they compete with resale homes on closing date as well as price. A buyer who needs to close by year end can choose either one.
For a buyer, all of this changes the questions worth asking about a resale home. Comparing a list price with the last three sales on the street won't capture it.
For sellers, the same picture argues for pricing against the new-build alternative from the first day the home is listed. Waiting for the market to deliver price cuts one at a time is a weaker position.
Is the Cumming market falling? In Georgia MLS figures, Forsyth County's average sale price for September 2026 was about 5.5% below September 2025, on fewer sales. The 400 North brief described the August 2026 median as relatively steady at $619,000. Prices are softer, and the bigger change is in how many homes are competing for each buyer.
Do builder rate offers apply to every new home in Cumming? No. The offers listed here apply to select or eligible homes, have firm dates and, in some cases, require the builder's affiliated lender.
Why is the average list price so much higher than the average sale price? The active listings include higher-priced and newer homes, and many have been on the market as sales slowed. In September 2026, the homes that closed averaged $680,661, while current listings average $820,708.
Whether you're buying or selling in Cumming, the question this fall is how your home or your offer compares with a nearby new build on monthly payment. Julia Sosa-Rocha and our team can run that comparison for your specific property, in English or Russian, and price it against the builder offers actually available in Forsyth County this month. Request Your Free Home Valuation to see where your home stands.
Stay up to date on the latest real estate trends.
If you are looking for top, proven, passionate agents that you can trust, who will aggressively represent you and your best interests only, who will give you attention & who are passionate about making sure you have an exceptional, positive experience in buying or selling your home, please call us today & we will be glad to help!